The first review of “The Catholic Marriage Bed”

My book, The Catholic Marriage Bed, received its first Amazon review here. Lots of personal insults not related to the book. Some unrelated criticism of my believe in Medjugorje and my work in eschatology. A good deal of name-calling. But, all in all, he liked it. Two stars. Bizarre review.

On a related note, what do my readers think of Christopher West and Gregory Popcak? What do you think of the theology of the body?

Advertisements
Gallery | This entry was posted in commentary. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to The first review of “The Catholic Marriage Bed”

  1. Matt Z. says:

    I own the book, I am half way through. Expect a solid review from me.

  2. Francisco says:

    I’m not particularly familiar with the work of Gregory Popcak. However, i know that Christopher West’s version of theology of the body is very distorted in comparison with the real TOTB by St. JP2.

    Alice M. von Hildebrand made a very good critique of Christopher West’s work:

    https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/document/dietrich-von-hildebrand-catholic-philosopher-and-christopher-west-modern-enthusiasttwo-very-different-approaches-to-love-marriage-and-sex-999

    What I find troubling is that many young people who is sincerely interested to learn about TOTB goes to Wes’s distorted version. I tell them not to go to that distorted version, but instead to go to the Real TOTB by St. JP2.

    • Ron Conte says:

      The real TOB is theologically and philosophically dense, so they can’t penetrate its meaning. Then the dumbed-down version by West introduces all kinds of grave errors, but is easy to understand. Some of these bishops just seem happy that crowds of people are excited about religion; they don’t care that it is filled with grave error.

  3. Amanda says:

    I just bought your book from Amazon. I’m not very far yet, still getting through the introduction. I’m actually writing a paper on pretty much the exact same thing—challenging the views of West and Popcak on what they consider licit in marriage. I had no clue someone else already had this idea. Praise God! I am also using the Magisterium, Scripture, the saints and modern writers like Alice von Hildebrand to refute their claims. I am finding your book very helpful in helping me to find sources. It’s refreshing to finally find a writer on this topic who agrees that marriage doesn’t give people license to be beasts. God bless you.

Comments are closed.